Bireme Capital
  • Home
  • Blog
  • CIO Corner
  • In the news
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Store

Bollore: 2.9B shares outstanding – or is it 1.4B?

7/16/2019

 

One of our favorite current holdings, Bollore SA, is a conglomerate that we think trades at a large discount to fundamental value. Bollore has an underappreciated and rapidly growing asset in music label Universal Music Group though Bollore's stake in Vivendi. Bollore also offers a large discount at the corporate level driven by availability bias, a bias that causes shareholders to focus on the most available information – in this case, the reported share count.

The share count as disclosed in Bollore’s financial statements (2.9b) is actually more than twice the economic shares outstanding (1.4b by our calculation). The true economic share count is smaller than the reported figure because most Bollore shares are self-owned by subsidiaries in a complicated web of crossholdings. We suspect that many investors have overlooked this information due to its obscurity, or ignored it due to its complexity. This has caused them to undervalue Bollore by a factor of two. At Bireme, we've meticulously analyzed and transformed the crossholding data into a graphic that we think demonstrates our claim about the share count in a clear and intuitive way.

In the figure we’ve created below, each row represents an upstream holding company affiliated with Bollore. As many of the upstream companies which own pieces of Bollore are partially owned by Bollore itself, self-ownership accumulates as we travel down the graph towards the operating company.

The final row shows the true economic ownership of Bollore after accumulated self-ownership has been subtracted out. 52.1% of Bollore’s outstanding shares are indirectly self-owned. They should be treated as treasury shares and can be subtracted from the total share count. Thus, public shareholders actually own 74.5% of Bollore, rather than the reported 35.7%.


Read More

Comments are closed.

      Follow our blog.

    Subscribe

    Schedule time with me!

    Follow @evantindell
    Tweets by evantindell

Telephone

813-603-2615

Email

info@biremecapital.com

Disclaimer

See here for important disclosures and see here for our fees.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • CIO Corner
  • In the news
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Store